Bunnings has removed a straitjacket Halloween costume from its online marketplace after criticism from mental health organisation SANE Australia. Taking it down was the right response. The more revealing question is how a costume built around treating psychiatric patients as frightening became part of the range offered under such a familiar retail name.
In its 31 October reporting, the ABC describes a costume with arm ties and a printed warning linking a mental institution with danger. A Bunnings spokesperson told the broadcaster the company understood the concerns and had removed the listing once it was brought to its attention.
The removal concerns Bunnings Marketplace
The confirmed action applies to an online marketplace listing. Bunnings’ response to the ABC describes a concern being raised and the item being taken down. Keeping that detail attached to the story makes clear which part of the retailer’s shopping experience is under scrutiny.
Bunnings’ own Marketplace page presents the service as an expanded range supplied through its sellers. The page uses the phrase “Trusted Sellers” and places that range within the retailer’s shopping experience.
A marketplace can make more products available without putting each one on a warehouse shelf. It also creates more opportunities for a poor listing to reach customers through a brand they already know. The commercial attraction of a larger range comes with an obvious editorial and merchandising challenge: someone still has to decide what belongs there.
Customers do not need to study the fulfilment arrangements before recognising the name at the top of the page. That is why an outside seller’s involvement would not make the reputational question disappear.
SANE’s objection is about the person inside the costume
SANE chief executive Rachel Green told the ABC that businesses should not publicly support mental health causes while profiting from products that reinforce stigma. SANE ambassador and author Sandy Jeffs, who lives with schizophrenia, also criticised the portrayal of people with mental illness as objects of ridicule or fear.
Their objection is specific enough to engage with. A straitjacket costume labelled as a warning about psychiatric patients turns a real group of people into the source of the scare. The outfit’s joke depends on that association before the wearer has said a word.
SANE’s explanation of mental health stigma focuses on people being judged or treated differently because of their mental health. The organisation links that problem to everyday experiences, including representation in news and entertainment. Its criticism of the costume sits within that wider advocacy work.
Halloween has a vast vocabulary to draw from. Our 2026 costume guide ranges across games, films, music and internet culture. There is plenty of room for an instantly recognisable character, a clever homemade outfit or an elaborate creature without relying on a caricature of a patient.
A takedown is useful; a better selection process would be better
Bunnings’ reported response addresses the immediate listing. The next useful question for any marketplace is how its selection and review processes catch this kind of problem before advocates have to point it out. A retailer can act on feedback and still examine how the product reached the site.
There is no need to pretend every shopper wants the same Halloween. Some families prefer character-led fun with fewer scares. Others are happily working through a seasonal horror watchlist. Retailers already make choices about audience, tone and which products deserve space in their range.
Listening to the people represented by a costume is part of making those choices well. Bunnings has removed this listing. The worthwhile standard is a shopping experience in which a familiar brand’s promise of trust also reaches the products offered through its marketplace.


The conversation
Be the first to join the conversation.