Taika Waititi has answered the poor reviews for Klara and the Sun by attacking the people writing them. His Halloween Instagram post celebrates an audience score, then dismisses critics as frustrated would-be artists. The film’s reception has become a row about who gets to judge it.

In the 31 October post, Waititi says he has avoided reviews of his work and his peers for almost 15 years, while listening to audiences. He calls critics “sad lost souls” who failed to become artists and links the response to those who disliked Jojo Rabbit.

The image he shared promotes a 78% Rotten Tomatoes audience score for Klara and the Sun. It is a figure in that dated promotional graphic, rather than a live score being reported here. The post itself is the new development, following the early review debate we covered in October.

What an audience score actually measures

There is nothing strange about a director being glad that some viewers enjoy a film critics dislike. Nor does enjoying it require anyone to apologise for their taste. The leap comes when that enjoyment is presented as a reason to dismiss the people who reached a different conclusion.

Rotten Tomatoes explains in its own FAQ that the Tomatometer measures the proportion of approved critics’ reviews classified as positive. The Popcornmeter comes from user ratings. These are different groups contributing different kinds of responses.

Neither percentage is an average mark out of 100. A 78% audience figure does not mean the average viewer awarded 78 out of 100, and the two groups are not competing ballots in a single election. Scores can also change as more reviews and ratings arrive.

A percentage alone cannot establish a box-office comeback, either. Ratings and tickets sold are different measures. The audience figure can be a reason for a curious viewer to look further; it cannot tell them whether the particular qualities criticised in a review will bother them.

Guide explaining the critic and audience groups behind the Tomatometer and Popcornmeter
POPTOPIC guide based on Rotten Tomatoes’ score definitions. Original diagram; it does not show live scores.

The argument is about an adaptation’s tone

The official film synopsis introduces Jenna Ortega’s Klara as an Artificial Friend who finds a connection with Josie, played by Mia Tharia. Amy Adams plays Josie’s mother. The screenplay, by Waititi and Dahvi Waller, adapts Kazuo Ishiguro’s novel.

That source material gives the disagreement something more substantial than a red or green badge. Guy Lodge’s Variety review argues that Waititi’s broad whimsy clashes with Ishiguro’s restrained sadness and interior perspective. A viewer can disagree with that assessment, but it is an argument about choices on screen.

Sony’s synopsis, meanwhile, foregrounds Klara’s innocence, loyalty and ability to bring warmth to a grieving family. There is room for someone to find those qualities moving while another person finds the treatment too sweet. Explaining that difference is more useful than diagnosing either person’s ambitions.

Kazuo Ishiguro speaking in Stockholm in December 2017
Klara and the Sun author Kazuo Ishiguro in Stockholm in December 2017. Archive photo: Frankie Fouganthin, via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0.

Let the disagreement do some work

We have seen divided reception become part of the pitch before. The marketing around Digger made disagreement a selling point. Our Verity review roundup found critics returning to Anne Hathaway’s performance even when their overall verdicts differed. Reading the reasons gives audiences something to use.

Waititi has every right to defend his film, and a punishing reception can sting after years of work. But the suggestion that critics are simply unsuccessful artists answers a question nobody needs resolved before buying a ticket. It leaves the actual objections waiting.

People who love Klara and the Sun can make a better case for it by describing what reached them: a performance, a joke, a moment of tenderness. That conversation might persuade someone to give the film a chance. Speculating about a critic’s failed dreams tells them very little about the movie.

About the author

Dianne Anders

Aspired to be a film maker, settled for writing about films. You'll usually find me at the cinema or yelling at the TV. I'm a private, paranoid person. A little unhinged, but in the good way.

Explore:
Back to Discover ↑Your saved stories

The conversation

Be the first to join the conversation.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments follow POPTOPIC’s moderation settings.